Friday, December 23, 2022

The Horse, the Wheel, and Language

By David W. Anthony

This book explores the origin and spread of Indo-European languages. It's my first exposure to analytic archeology, and linguistic archeology. 

Analytic archeology example-- With the right horse bones, you can tell how old the horse was when that horse died. In a herd of wild horses, the age of the horses are distributed. If those horses were slaughtered and left in a heap, then the age of their bones are also distributed. For domesticated horses, males are slaughtered at about two years and females at about age six. 

So, while you can't look at a single horse bone and know if the horse was wild or domesticated, you can look at a heap of horse bones and see how the ages cluster. If they cluster around age two and six, then those bones were from domesticated horses.

Linguistic archeology-- how much can you learn about a people, not from their language, which is dead and gone, but from their daughter languages? How do linguists know when a word is borrowed from another language, or when a word is similar between the two languages because they share the same parent language?

If daughter languages contain similar words for wheel, cart and axil, then you can be fairly certain that the parent language had the same, and that the parent society had wheels and carts with axils.





Tuesday, December 13, 2022

The Day the Universe Changed

By James Burke

Science as truth-- science sees the truths that the current systems-of-belife agree are truths, and calls out the mistakes made by past systems. Things get squishy when you discuss mistakes made the current system of belief.

I enjoyed this book. It's difficult for me to take a lesson from this book other than "Things are complicated and happen for complicated reasons. Beware of narratives that tell simple stories."